Recent Blog Posts

What is Review Gating?
Updated 05-22-2025
Review Recency Matters for Google Business Profile Ranking
Updated 05-06-2025

Review Gating in the Home Service Industry: What Contractors Need to Know

By the Red Barn Media Group Team

As a home service contractor, your online reputation can make or break your business. In today's digital-first world, potential customers are making decisions about which HVAC technician to call, which plumber to hire, or which electrician to trust based largely on your Google reviews.

But with this emphasis on reviews comes a temptation that many contractors fall prey to: review gating. At Red Barn Media Group, we've spent 25+ years helping home service businesses build legitimate digital marketing strategies that drive real growth. Today, we're tackling the controversial practice of review gating and why it's something every contractor needs to understand.

What is Review Gating?

Review gating is a practice where businesses filter which customers are asked to leave public reviews. The typical process works like this:

1. After a service call, you send the customer a satisfaction survey or feedback form
2. If they indicate they had a positive experience, they're directed to leave a review on Google, Facebook, or another platform
3. If they indicate they had a negative experience, they're sent to a private feedback form instead and never prompted to leave a public review

This creates a "gate" that only allows satisfied customers through to your public review profiles, artificially inflating your star rating.

Why Home Service Contractors Are Tempted

We get it. The temptation is real, especially in the home service industry:

• A plumbing emergency can be stressful, and customers might leave a negative review even when you resolved their issue promptly
• HVAC installations are expensive, and sticker shock might lead to poor ratings even when the work was excellent
• Electrical work is technical, and customers might not understand why certain safety procedures were necessary

It's particularly tempting for contractors because each negative review can feel deeply personal—it's your craftsmanship, your team, and your livelihood on the line.

Why Review Gating Is a Dangerous Game

Despite these understandable concerns, at Red Barn Media Group, we strongly advise our home service clients against review gating practices for several critical reasons:

1. It Violates Google's Guidelines

In April 2018, Google updated its review policy to explicitly prohibit "discouraging or prohibiting negative reviews or selectively soliciting positive reviews from customers."

For home service businesses that depend heavily on local search visibility, violating Google's policies is a significant risk. We've seen cases where contractors had 80% of their reviews removed after being reported for review gating.

2. The FTC Can Issue Significant Penalties

The Federal Trade Commission considers review gating a deceptive practice that creates a misleading impression of your business. In recent enforcement actions, companies have faced fines in the millions of dollars for manipulating their review profiles.

As a local contractor, even a smaller fine could devastate your business.

3. It Damages Trust in the Long Run

When your 5-star rating doesn't match the occasional service hiccups that are inevitable in any home service business, customers feel misled. This erosion of trust is particularly damaging in an industry built on inviting strangers into your home.

4. You Miss Valuable Feedback

Those negative reviews you're filtering out? They contain gold—specific insights on how to improve your business. By gating reviews, you're missing opportunities to identify training needs, process improvements, or service gaps.

What Research Tells Us About Review Gating

At Red Barn Media Group, we believe in making decisions based on data, not just opinion. Here's what research has uncovered about review gating:

The Impact on Review Volume and Ratings

A landmark study by GatherUp examined approximately 10,000 business locations before and after they stopped review gating. The results were eye-opening:

• Review volume increased by nearly 70% when businesses stopped filtering reviews
• Average star ratings only decreased slightly—from 4.66 to 4.59 on Google
• The massive increase in review quantity far outweighed the minimal impact on average ratings

According to Mike Blumenthal, co-founder of GatherUp: "The impact of not gating review requests on average star-rating was very small... so small that in any given business it likely didn't even impact the rating score at all."

The Financial Impact of Reviews

For home service contractors, the financial implications of authentic reviews are significant:

• Businesses with 4 to 5-star ratings earn an additional 28% in annual revenue according to research from Edge
• A Harvard Business School study found that a one-star decrease in ratings could lead to a 5-9% decrease in revenue
• Interestingly, research by Womply found that businesses with perfect 5-star ratings actually earned less than those with ratings between 4.2 and 4.5 stars

This last point is particularly important—consumers are suspicious of perfect ratings. They understand that even the best contractors occasionally face challenges, and a few constructive negative reviews actually build credibility.

How Reviews Impact Local SEO Rankings

According to Search Engine Journal, reviews play a crucial role in local search rankings for home service contractors. Sherry Bonelli, a Google Business Profile expert, explains that "online reviews are important to local businesses" for several key reasons:

Google Confirms Reviews Affect Rankings

Google's own Business Profile Help Guide explicitly states that reviews can help your local ranking. As Bonelli notes, "reviews can influence both the Google Local Pack and Local Finder rankings as well as local organic rankings."

For home service contractors competing in crowded markets like HVAC, plumbing, and electrical services, this can make the difference between showing up on the first page of results or being buried on page three.

Reviews Create Rich Snippets

When your business accumulates quality reviews, Google may display "Review Snippets" in your Knowledge Panel. These snippets highlight specific positive aspects of your service that customers have mentioned repeatedly, making your listing stand out from competitors.

According to recent research published on Search Engine Land, Google took down over 240 million policy-violating reviews in 2024 alone—a 40% increase from the previous year. This aggressive enforcement shows just how seriously Google takes review manipulation tactics, including review gating.

1. It's Against Platform Policies

Google, Yelp, Facebook, and other review platforms explicitly prohibit purchasing reviews. Their sophisticated algorithms are increasingly effective at identifying suspicious review patterns, and the penalties are severe—including business profile suspension.

2. It's Illegal

The FTC considers purchased reviews to be a form of false advertising. Recent enforcement actions have targeted not just the businesses buying reviews but also the services selling them. In 2022, the FTC fined the clothing retailer Fashion Nova $4.2 million for suppressing negative reviews—a stark warning to businesses considering similar practices.

3. Customers Can Spot Fake Reviews

Today's consumers are savvy. A 2022 PowerReviews survey found that 90% of consumers believe they've encountered fake reviews, and they identify them by looking for red flags including extreme language, lack of specific details, and unrealistically positive claims. When potential customers spot fake reviews, the damage to your reputation is far worse than any negative review could be.

4. Fake Reviews Have Serious Economic Consequences

Recent research indicates that fake reviews cost U.S. businesses nearly $152 billion annually due to damaged reputations and lost sales opportunities. A 2025 study found that approximately 30% of online reviews may be fabricated, leading to significant consumer trust issues and unfair competition.

5. It Undermines Legitimate Feedback

When you flood your profile with purchased reviews, you dilute the value of genuine feedback from real customers who took time to share their experience with your service.

The FTC's Growing Focus on Review Practices

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has significantly increased its enforcement actions against deceptive review practices. In January 2022, they published a guide for businesses titled "Featuring Online Customer Reviews: A Guide for Platforms," which outlines clear principles for review collection:

• Don't selectively ask for reviews based on sentiment
• Don't suppress or hide negative reviews
• Disclose if there are material connections between reviewers and the business
• Have processes to identify and handle fake reviews

These guidelines aren't just suggestions—the FTC has shown they're willing to pursue significant penalties against violators.

How Authentic Reviews Actually Help Your Business

For home service contractors, authentic reviews aren't just about maintaining compliance—they're powerful business tools:

1. Reviews Drive Local Search Rankings

Google's algorithm heavily weighs review quantity, quality, and recency when determining local search rankings. Our clients who focus on generating legitimate reviews consistently outrank competitors in local searches for "plumber near me" or "HVAC contractor."

2. Reviews Build Trust With Skeptical Homeowners

According to a 2025 Trustmary study, 93% of consumers read reviews before purchasing, and 81% say they need to trust a brand before making a purchase decision. Authentic reviews that acknowledge both strengths and occasional weaknesses feel more believable to potential customers than perfect 5-star profiles.

3. Positive Reviews Drive Revenue

Research shows that customers spend up to 31% more on products with excellent reviews, and a 2025 study found that 92% of B2B buyers are more likely to purchase after reading a trusted review. For home service businesses that depend on high-ticket jobs like HVAC installations or bathroom remodels, this can translate to thousands of dollars in additional revenue.

4. Negative Reviews Aren't As Harmful As You Think

A surprising finding from Northwestern University and PowerReviews found that purchase probability actually peaks with an average rating of 4.2-4.5 stars—not 5.0. Customers are suspicious of perfect ratings and often read negative reviews first to understand worst-case scenarios.

5. Reviews Create Opportunities for Re-engagement

Responding to reviews opens a channel for continued conversation with past customers, creating opportunities for service reminders, maintenance plans, or referral requests. Studies show that 53% of customers expect businesses to respond to negative reviews within a week, yet 87% of businesses don't address them at all—creating an easy opportunity to stand out from competitors.

Better Alternatives for Home Service Contractors

After helping hundreds of HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and construction businesses build their online presence, we've developed approaches that build a strong review profile without crossing ethical and legal lines:

1. Embrace Transparency

Ask all your customers for reviews, not just the happy ones. We've found that when home service contractors are transparent, they actually build deeper trust with their community.

2. Make Reviews Part of Your Process

Train your technicians to mention reviews at the end of each job. A simple "Would you mind taking a moment to leave us feedback on Google? It really helps our small business" can dramatically increase your review count.

3. Respond to Every Review

When you get a negative review (and you will), respond professionally and constructively. Our data shows that potential customers are often more impressed by how you handle criticism than by a perfect rating.

4. Use Technology Wisely

Implement a review management system that makes it easy for customers to leave reviews without filtering based on sentiment. Our clients have seen up to a 300% increase in reviews by simply making the process easier.

5. Focus on Service Recovery

Rather than hiding negative experiences, put energy into service recovery when things go wrong. A customer whose problem was proactively solved often becomes your biggest advocate.

The Bottom Line for Contractors

In our 25+ years working with home service businesses, one truth stands out: authenticity wins in the long run. The contractors who thrive aren't the ones with artificially perfect reviews—they're the ones who deliver consistent quality, take ownership when things go wrong, and build genuine relationships with their communities.

At Red Barn Media Group, we're committed to helping our home service clients build marketing strategies that not only drive leads but stand the test of time. Review gating might seem like a shortcut to a stellar online reputation, but the risks far outweigh the rewards.

Instead, focus on delivering exceptional service that naturally generates positive reviews, and embrace the occasional negative feedback as an opportunity to demonstrate your professionalism and commitment to customer satisfaction.

Your online reputation is too valuable to risk on short-term tactics that could undermine your business's long-term success. If you'd like to discuss ethical and effective review management strategies tailored to your home service business, we're here to help.

Red Barn Media Group specializes in digital marketing for home service contractors. With over 25 years of industry experience, we understand the unique challenges HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and construction businesses face in building their online presence. Contact us today to learn how we can help your business thrive in the digital landscape.

Last update 05-22-2025